Insecure workers face “triple hit” of pandemic hardship, says Citizens Advice
With the number of people on zero-hour contracts at an all time high of 1 million, a leading charity has warned of an unfolding workers’ rights crisis.
New research from Citizens Advice found agency workers and those on zero-hours contracts, including “gig economy” workers, were more likely to have seen their employment rights violated, faced job losses and lost income during the pandemic compared to the rest of the working population.
More than half (52%) of insecure workers classed themselves as key workers. Compared to the rest of the working population insecure workers were on average:
Four times more likely to have faced losing their job
Three times more likely to have been made to work while ill and to have not been paid wages they were owed
One and half times more likely to have lost income, with those who had lost income averaging a loss of £1,000 a month since March
The charity’s advisers have seen worrying examples of potential employment rights violations. These include an agency worker who was told to ‘self isolate’ and sent home without pay from her factory job after she told management staff she was pregnant, and an agency worker who was denied sick pay they were entitled to after testing positive for Covid.
Citizens Advice warns many insecure workers are struggling to understand their rights or defend them due to a complex and patchwork system for employment enforcement.
“I spent a whole day advising care workers on zero-hours contracts”
Alex McColl is a frontline adviser at Citizens Advice Sheffield. He says: “What really came across in this pandemic is just how precarious you are as an insecure worker. When tough times came around they were often the ones who lost their jobs, were denied access to the furlough scheme or saw wages withheld.
“I spent a whole day advising care workers on zero-hours contracts. One had lost their job because they’d refused to go into the home of someone with Covid symptoms. Another raised concerns over health and safety at their workplace and was subsequently given duties cleaning a Covid ward. They felt it was punishment for speaking up.”
“We should be looking forward to Christmas but all I’m thinking about is paying the bills”
Sharon has worked as a childcare assistant in a creche for more than 9 years. She was employed on a zero-hours contract despite working a set pattern of 18 hours a week.
When lockdown hit, Sharon’s workplace was shut and she was furloughed. In September Sharon’s employer took her off furlough but did not give her any work. Her employer said that she was expected to be on standby. Sharon asked to receive redundancy pay instead and she was refused despite her local Citizens Advice establishing that she likely met the legal definition of an employee and would therefore be eligible.
Sharon says: “It's been a real struggle financially. My partner is having to make up the shortfall in our income and that’s put a strain on everything. We should be looking forward to Christmas but all I’m thinking about is paying the bills.
“It’s also been a struggle mentally. I try to stay positive as I’m sure there are people worse off than me, but it feels really hopeless given there are no jobs around. I thought being with my employer for a long time would give me some security, so it’s gutting to be in this situation.”
Alistair Cromwell, Acting Chief Executive of Citizens Advice, said:
“Zero-hours and agency workers, including delivery drivers and carers, have often been at the frontline of this pandemic.
“Yet they’ve faced a triple hit of hardship: more likely to face losing their jobs, have their employment rights violated and experience stark drops in income.
“It’s not right that the rights insecure workers have aren’t always being upheld. The government must fast-track its plans to create a one-stop shop for employment rights to ensure that all workers, including people in the most precarious positions, are protected.”
Frontline staff at Citizens Advice have helped more than 170,000 people with one-to-one advice on employment issues since lockdown. The charity has seen an 89% increase in people seeking help because of issues with the terms and conditions of their temporary, agency or zero-hours contract compared to the same period last year.
There are six national organisations which enforce workers’ rights, but workers who have been unfairly sacked or treated often can’t call for their situation to be investigated. While they could take their issue to an employment tribunal, previous research by Citizens Advice showed the employment tribunal backlog could pass 500,000 cases as a result of Covid.
Notes to editors
See the full report ‘On the Edge: Insecure work in the pandemic’ for more information.
Office for National Statistics (2020), People in employment on zero hours contracts
ICM polling of a representative, weighted sample of 6,004 adults (aged 18+) living in the UK. Survey between 12 November and 25 November 2020 during the second national lockdown.
This includes a base sample of 816 people classed as in “insecure work.” Insecure workers include those who have an employment contract with an employment agency, work for an agency that sends them to multiple companies, and people with zero-hours contracts.
Respondents were asked ‘Have you either lost your job since the beginning of the pandemic, or are you in the process of losing your job now?. Those who answered ‘Yes, I have lost my job’, ‘Yes - I have had informal discussions with my employer about losing my job’ or 'Yes - my employer has started a formal redundancy or dismissal process’ are regarded as facing a job loss.
All employed respondents were asked ‘Since the beginning of the pandemic have you experienced any of the following problems at work?’. 747 respondents were either employed on a zero-hours contract or for an agency.
9.2% of respondents who were employed on zero-hours contracts and/or through an employment agency had been made to work while ill, compared with 3.1% of all employed workers.
8.7% of respondents who were employed on zero-hours contracts and/or through an employment agency had not been paid wages they were owed, compared with 3.5% of all employed workers.
63% insecure workers have lost income compared to 40% of all workers.
Citizens Advice has seen a 89% increase in people helped because of issues with the terms and conditions of their temporary, agency or zero-hours contract compared to the same period last year (23rd March - 9th December). Actual numbers are 1,736 in 2019 and 3,275 in 2020.
Citizens Advice’s report An Unequal Crisis found that disabled people, those asked to shield, and parents and carers are at least twice as likely to be facing redundancy as the rest of the working population.
Citizens Advice is made up of the national charity Citizens Advice; the network of independent local Citizens Advice charities across England and Wales; the Citizens Advice consumer service; and the Witness Service.
Our network of charities offers impartial advice online and over the phone, for free.
We helped 2.8 million people face to face, over the phone, by email and webchat in 2019-20. And we had 34.5 million visits to our website. For full service statistics see our monthly publication Advice trends.
You can get consumer advice from the Citizens Advice consumer service on 0808 223 1133 or 0808 223 1144 for Welsh language speakers.